Wednesday 15 February 2012

Look in the mirror Allardyce, then point the finger!

Question: can anybody remember West Ham collecting four red cards in a season? It may have happened in 2003-04 because Defoe was on a mission to get a transfer and was collecting red cards like other teenagers were collecting Pokemon cards (for those that don't remember, he picked up three), but even when Hutchison, Dicks and Mad Dog were in Claret and Blue, I don't remember four red cards in the first two thirds of a season.

It's true that red cards are issued more liberally these days, but players know the rules and have a duty not to push the envelope, thereby forcing a referee's hand. So why is it happening?

Well if a manager automatically blames the referee and publicly defends his players, is it any wonder that they behave irresponsibly? Taylor was stupid last night - bloody stupid - but rather than criticise him, Allardyce  chose to quibble over whether hands were raised to the chest or face. Who cares? We had just been awarded a penalty so what the hell did Taylor think he was doing? His actions were crass and irresponsible as Vaz Te appeared to tell him after the card was shown. So why the hell hasn't Allardyce said that? Instead of arguing about the decision to show red, why isn't Allardyce saying what most West Ham fans believe, that Taylor let the club down and cost us the game?

But a pattern has already been established hasn't it? Kebe was criticised by Allardyce for provoking Collison's assault at Reading and, unbelievably, Nolan's horror tackle in the Millwall game was also defended despite the powder keg nature of that fixture. What message does this give to the players exactly? Well, Taylor's idiotic conduct last night answers that question doesn't it? If the manager endorses thuggery, why shouldn't the players behave like thugs?

Would Greenwood have behaved like Allardyce? Or Lyall? Or Clough? I can hear Clough now. "The boy was bloody stupid and it will cost him three weeks wages for the time he is suspended." Now, had Allardyce adopted that approach after Nolan's red card, would Taylor have rushed in, fool like, last night? Of course not!

Instead of blaming the officials, Allardyce should point the finger at his own reflection. This is a team in the image of the manager, and like the manager, it considers itself above reproach. Collison let the club down at Reading, Nolan did the same against Millwall and Taylor repeated the offence last night. All three should have been fined and publicly reprimanded. Perhaps then we might keep 11 players on the pitch for the duration of a game!

11 comments:

Rrrrroger said...

Whats up? no QPR news? You're talking shite - go to the toilet HF

Anonymous said...

Discipline in private, praise in public. Pretty standard management in any field.

Anonymous said...

come on the manager is supposed to defend his players.

Slagging them off in public isn't going to do any good.

I'm sure privately they are getting a rollocking from fat Sam.

Anonymous said...

this article proves your fragile little mind has been warped by the media

Hammersfan said...

To those who are claiming that there is public support but a private rollicking, please explain how that helps? Do you like being treated as an idiot by Allardyce? If he is angry with Nolan and Taylor, why shouldn't you know about it? As I state in the article, Clough was always very frank in public and I think you will find that he achieved a hell of a lot more in the game than Allardyce!

Anonymous said...

Anony-mouse says,

I don't know what you do for a living but if you make a bad mistake would you really like your boss to c*nt you off in front of all your workmates? Would that get the best out of you? Would you feel supported and feel like giving 110% for your gaffer? Would you not find it humiliating. Alternatively, would you prefer he had a word in your ear in private, to make sure it didn't happen again. I'd go with option B myself.

And the Sam way seems to be working as the team spirit shown in the last two games in particular has been absolutely first rate.

By all means mention Clough. But for every great like Cloughie who'd do it your way there are more greats who wouldn't. Ferguson, Wenger....

Dagenham Dave said...

Different day, same shit

Hammersfan said...

Could be a motto for Allardyce's career DD!

Dagenham Dave said...

HF top of the league with a game in hand last time I looked, accept him as out manager and enjoy the ride, otherwise your bitterness will consume you, if it hasn't already

Hammersfan said...

With respect, Hitler turned Germany around economically and, if judged on economics alone, did a reasonable job for a brief period of time. And no, I am not comparing Allardyce to Hitler, I am simply saying that sometimes you have to look at the bigger picture. Where are we in the Championship form table since the beginning of December?

davefking said...

I've worked with managers that have backed me in bad times. I've worked with managers that have hang me out to dry. We all fuck up from time to time, its human nature. Guess which manager got the best out of me?