Thursday, 27 August 2009
Arsenal Cheats - Just Like The Rest Of Us!
Yep Eduardo took a dive and won Arsenal a crucial penalty, but until FIFA, UEFA the FA or whoever take decisive action, this isn't going to stop. Yes Eduardo is a cheat but so is Jimenez - he clearly threw himself to the ground in the box against Spurs - and Owen - remember roaring approval as he gave the Argies a taste of their own medicine?
Pundits say this came into our game with the foreigners but they have very short memories obviously. I offer you Francis Lee and Alan Clarke as England strikers well versed in the black arts of diving in the box as long ago as the early 1970s. Lee flew through the air like the proverbial bomb whilst Clarke favoured the "shot in the small of the back by a sniper" technique, agony twisting his features as his trailing leg kissed the flesh of an opposing defender and he crumpled to the ground in three staged stylish movements (the older amongst you will see a mind's eye picture as you read this).
It happened much less often in those days of course - not because the players were doing it less often perhaps but more likely because there weren't TV cameras at every ground to pick it up and replay it over and over again in slow motion when a player took a tumble. Summerbee was a master at it if I remember rightly. Giles got fantastic elevation at the slightest hint of a challenge and with Lorimer in the team, he sometimes dived out of the box to set up a free kick from just outside the area! You can probably identify when this came into the game - it probably coincided with players disputing decisions with the referees - and that did not start with Roy Keane at Manchester United!
The solutions are simple of course. Cricket and tennis are using technology to assist officials and this has added to the drama. The tension as a decision goes to the third umpire is incredible and the roar or groan that accompanies the decision is like another wicket being taken. Holding up the game? So what, add it on at the end of the match for pity's sake.
Then there is the power to overturn results. If Celtic were now going into the next round, would Arsene maintain his "I could not see it personally" approach? Eduardo would never kick a ball for Arsenal again in those circumstances! Too harsh on the rest of the team? Why, the whole team benefit from the cheating. Perhaps then, the captain might ask the player concerned, "Are you sure about that one, we don't want to be eliminated for cheating."
And of course a cheat can be banned as Rugby Union has just proved. Biting on a blood capsule is pretty low but is it any worse than diving to win a penalty or to get an opponent sent off? If Eduardo now faced a 3 month ban, without wages, he would think twice before doing it again wouldn't he?
So why are the authorities sitting on their hands? Why are the rules a cheat's charter? I'm not condemning Eduardo or Arsenal here, that would be hypocritical. Every player that takes a dive does so because the authorities accept it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
8 comments:
Your post is indeed the most sensible I have read since the final whistle went last night. Unbelievable the amount of flack Eduardo is getting. THIS HAPPENS EVERY WEEK IN ALL LEAGUES AND WHEN CELTIC PLAY AT HOME THEY ENJOY THE BENEFIT OF THESE DECISIONS
Well done hammers fan (bet you aint seen that this week)
for one you have written an article that i agree with, personally the media are taking this way out of hand, where was the BAN DROGBA every match he dived
that will never happen
in south america diving is seen as a skill.
Also technology assisting the referees with the exception of goal line technology will only slow the game down
so im afraid i dont agree
diving is like taking performance enhancing drugs in athletics... it's cheating.
and it should be punished in a similar fashion.
LOL Paul, actually the wife says it every night ; ]
Charlie, how would it slow the game down. The cameras showed it was a dive before the Celtic keeper had finished disputing the award. It would have sped the game up!
Any player found guilty of this should get a 5 game ban which can be given after video evidence it would imo hurt the club involved through wages and loss of player thus encouraging the said club to stamp it out. salty.
Couldn't agree more the way to stop is to suspend a player, red card sanction, cheating should be stamped out. It can be done a player can get punished for a punch etc based on video evidence.
I don't think a straight red for simulation is needed tho cos refs sometimes get those wrong
The argument against technology is sound too (I personally don't agree and think it should be introduced)in that football is a simple game and if it was law every club would have to have it and that wouldn't work on Wanstead flats (my argument it can be used in the same way that premier clubs have to have all seater stadia rather than a football rule) but the biggest counter is that the ref is human and fallible and that fallibility is an integral part of the game and the debate is also part of the game.
The ref getting it wrong I can handle,deliberately conning him or cheating I cannot abide but also refs should give the decision the man that tries to keep his feet and tries to play on but they never do do they? which is one of the main reasons players just go to ground because in that situation fairness is never rewarded
Post a Comment