Sunday 26 September 2010

Has the real Mark Noble just stood up?

There was so much to delight in yesterday: the no nonsense, get on with the job approach of Jacobsen; the saves of Green; the monumental defensive performance of Da Costa; the movement and skill of  both Obinna and Piquionne; the continued superb form of Parker; and the way that the team, in contrast to last season, played with energy, verve and desire ALLIED to shape and organisation. But for me, the most pleasing aspect of the performance was the way Mark Noble played. 

Noble is a player who triggers passionate debate amongst our fans. Many will excuse him anything, because he is "West Ham through and through" and an Academy product; others have written him off, claiming he is too slow and lacks the necessary skill to merit a place in a good Premiership team. This is odd given the type of player he is. You expect extreme reactions to players like Huddlestone, who appears languid and lazy at times, but Noble always plays with his heart on his sleeve, always gives his all, always tries 100%. The trouble is, some have argued, that Noble thinks he is better than he actually is, that he tries to be too clever and so looks a mug, regardless of his passion.

Noble has been through one hell of a journey for a guy who is not yet into his prime years. He started as a Joe Cole type but was remodelled by Pardew because of his lack of pace. He made his debut for the reserves aged just 15 - a record - suggesting that the club saw something VERY special in the boy. He is still only 23 but has been playing for the first team for 7 seasons, and has more than 100 Premiership games under his belt. That is part of the problem. Critics treat Noble as if he is 27 or 28, not a young player still finding his way in the game.

The last two seasons have been disappointing for Noble. His career undoubtedly stalled and probably went into reverse. But look what he had to deal with. England U21 duties meant that he went almost 20 months without having a break - that is one hell of a burden for a player whose all action style means that he never stops running. Then there was a deep seated injury which he struggled to shake off. Then there's the turmoil at the club. Noble has played under Pardew, Curbishley, Zola and now Grant, and has just got on with the job to the best of his ability, come rain or rain! Weaker individuals might have been crushed by what has been happening at the club. Then add to that Zola's use of Noble, playing him wide right and wide left, when the guy is patently suited only to playing in the centre of midfield, and is it any wonder that he looked "out of form".

Well yesterday, I saw the old Mark Noble, the Mark Noble that got us all so excited during the Great Escape, the Mark Noble that Arsene Wenger, of all people, considered buying. Now Wenger may not have an eye for a keeper but he does know a good midfielder when he sees one. The fact that he even considered Noble - even though he is English! - suggests that the boy has what it takes to succeed.

Yesterday wasn't a one off. Towards the end of last season, he was out of position but still holding his own in midfield and looking strong defensively, if still a little casual with his passing. Against Stoke, I thought he was excellent too, the senior partner in midfield in truth, which is saying something given the way Parker is playing this season! And yesterday, against a very strong Tottenham midfield unit, he looked absolute class. What impressed me most was his movement - the way he created passing opportunities for others. He looked like a genuine midfield general to me and, again, I thought his all round game was better than Parker's.

Regular contributor Stani Army has promised to run naked down the Barking Road if Noble gets more than one cap for England. Well, I think we should make that streak (or waddle mate?) a sponsored event with money going to the Bobby Moore cancer charity. Be warned Stani, I can see an England midfield five of Johnson, Rodwell, Noble, Wilshire and Milner come the next World Cup, with Walcott used as an impact sub!

6 comments:

Johntan said...

I think first of all we shouldn't get TOO carried away with this. It was just 1 performance after all. However what I saw yesterday from Noble has got me a bit excited. It seems he has been given licence to play more threatening passes unlike the endless sideways and backways passes that Zola had the players making. I have always thought it unfair to ask parker to be the more adventurous of a two man centre midfield partnership because its just not a job that he has the ability to do. He is a quality defensive midfielder why move him away from that job? This is why I was glad when we signed Hitz but now Noble seems to be puting his hand up to tell us he can do the job. But he has to play at the same level week in week out as I think that has been his main problem, consistency.

Hammersfan said...

But hhe is still young John. How many 21 and 22 year olds are consistent? At 23, Noble may be maturing and with maturity comes consistency - hopefully! But you are right, we must not get carried away yet. We musn't burden him with too much expectation. I am HOPEFUL!

ikeRNitr0 said...

He is still growing up and improving his skills, and the best is that he can learn from Parker and Hitz.

But his still so far away from the level of Lampard... Remember he was "the new Lampard" some years ago.

futbolporlavena.blogspot.com/2010/09/y-por-fin-llego-la-victoria.html

Stani Army said...

I've been seeing the real Noble for a long time :)

Obinna is 23 also.

With Collison at the club, Noble will not be able to keep his regular spot.

fred149 said...

stani why do u hate mark noble so much and if collison plays the way he did last year before he got injured then noble will not be getting dropped and everybody in pre season we saw noble hitz and parker playing as a midfield 3 so id like to kee pot that way

Stani Army said...

I don't hate him Fred. Hate is a strong word. I dont hate any of our players, not even Spector or Ben Haim....actually, Ben Haim's not really our player is he? I hate him then :)

My argument is that Noble has not and will not be good enough. He has been given special treatment by managers and fans just because of this crazy 'one of our own' fascination we have which has gotten us into trouble in the past (e.g. appointment of Curbishley). There's a big wide world out there and we need to open our minds or we will always be a small (relative) club.

The argument has always been that give Noble time and he will improve. But he's played over 100 first team games. How long do we wait? He has the odd good game and people forget everything. His good games are way too few and far between. The premier league is full of youngsters that have much better quality than Noble yet the way we go on about him, you'd think there was no one else.

Do you think he's better than Collison Fred?